(Full disclosure: While I am a veteran with an honorable
discharge, I never saw combat. I was never deployed overseas. I am in no way
comparing my service with those who have gone in harm’s way and acquitted
themselves with honor and valor.
We must not confuse dissent with disloyalty. --Edward R. Murrow
(Full disclosure: While I am a veteran with an honorable
discharge, I never saw combat. I was never deployed overseas. I am in no way
comparing my service with those who have gone in harm’s way and acquitted
themselves with honor and valor.
My spirit was willing to go to DC every day of the current five-day protest event.
·
The speakers need to take some public speaking
lessons. Ranting to a crowd that already agrees with you and is motivated
enough to come out doesn’t do much. Repeatedly chanting, “Trump must go!” doesn’t
move the ball. Tell us how you intend to do it.
·
Two notable exceptions: the DC congressional
delegate and a college student who came in from Connecticut. Both were eloquent
and inspiring, especially the student. I forgot my notebook so I don’t have
their names, but this young man may be someone to keep an eye on.
·
I made a point along the march to thank all the
groups of cops we passed, whether Metro, Park, or Capitol. Without exception
they smiled and nodded. There was no friction between the protestors and law
enforcement.
·
I came across a retired Army Master Sergeant in
full dress blues, hash marks to his elbow, and enough medals to make him list
to the left were he not such a formidable man. I thanked him for coming out, as
presences such as his refute the arguments made by MAGgots about the protestors
better than any verbal exchange. His reply: “I’m right where I’m needed: where
the fight is.” He carried a large “Fuck Trump” flag near the head of the entire
march.
·
I came to realize “Foxtrot Delta Tango” is used
as a military identifier. The Beloved Spouse™ bought me a shirt with that
embroidered on it; I wore it yesterday. On my way to the Mall a gentleman
passed me. Without preamble he asked, “Which branch?”
“Regular Army.”
“Marines. Have a good day.”
“Hoo-rah, Marine.”
He smiled.
·
One excellent speech had its message ripped out
when the speaker compared the non-violent protests we’re seeing now to the abolition
movement and how their non-violent protests got slavery abolished. Had I encountered
her later I would have reminded her of that whole Civil War thing.
·
A regular speaker at Refuse Fascism events is an
avowed Communist who openly says he wants not only to take down Trump, but the whole
“inherently corrupt system.” I ‘m all in on the anti-fascist aspects, but the
oath I swore that keeps me motivated against Trump also prevents me from
wanting anything to do with this guy, as I firmly believe the Constitution is
fine; it’s the people executing it who are fucked up. With that in mind, I think
of World War 2, where we had to partner with the Soviet Union to defeat
fascism. We need to work together to defeat Turmp, then the speaker and I can
go back to Cold War-ing each other.
The Beloved Spouse™ and I extended our trip to New Orleans for the Bouchercon readers’ conference by a couple of days to complete our tour of the World War II Museum. We went a few years ago when The Sole Heir was living in NOLA but, as advertised, you can’t do much more than scratch the surface of this museum in one day.
I’ll not go into everything we learned and enjoyed. The web site gives a good idea, but
you really need to go if you’re interested in the war. What I will talk about
today is the twenty-minute multi-media presentation we saw in the Freedom
Theater.
From the web site description:
The Priddy Family Foundation Freedom Theater … offers
audiences a multimedia experience focused on what was at stake during World War
II and the meaning of Allied victory. The production… highlights how freedom
almost vanished from the world in the 1930s and 1940s, efforts to protect and
promote freedom during and after World War II, and how each generation has a
responsibility to defend democracy, protect freedom, and advance human rights.
They should take this show on the road. Everyone needs to
see it.
For those who wonder how what happened in the 1930s and
1940s relates to us – and there are apparently a goodly number who do – the
parallels are striking. Events in Nazi Germany and fascist Italy so closely resemble
so much of what is taking place here and now that I felt uneasy through that
part of the presentation. Examples include:
·
Referring to people who were not members of the
ruling demographic as ‘sub-human.’ (Nazis: Jews. MAGA: immigrants.)
·
Blaming all the nation’s ills on those people.
·
Policies based on demonstrably false statements
that became more outrageous as time went on.
·
Denouncing anyone who dared point out these lies
as ‘enemies of the people’; or ‘enemies of the state.’
·
Violations of the rule of law to consolidate
power in an ever-tightening cadre of officials.
·
Claiming a leader with dictatorial powers is
what the people want.
I could go on, but you already stopped reading if you don’t
get the picture yet,.
Our fathers and grandfathers fought and died to prevent such
an ideology from taking over the world. It sickens me to see how many of their
descendants are not only accepting such an ethos, but welcome it. We stand at a
precipice where, in the words of John Stuart Mill, “Bad men need nothing more
to compass their ends, than that good men should look on and do nothing.” Or,
as Eldridge Cleaver said more recently, “There is no more neutrality in the
world. You either have to be part of the solution, or you're going to be part
of the problem.”
The time has passed for thoughts and prayers. Chicago showed
what can be done when the federal government, undone by a coup from within,
overreaches. The irony of who must stand up to a repressive government hellbent
on destroying our rights having been reversed 180 degrees from common
conservative dogma cannot be met with mere acknowledgement. Action is required.
Different people will be called to do different things based
on their abilities. Some are not physically able to march or demonstrate;
others may not be able to subject themselves to possible arrest or tear
gassing. Still more can’t afford to send money. That’s understood. Only about
ten percent of an army faces the enemy. Everyone else is support, and yours is
desperately needed.
Letters and phone calls are effective when sent in
sufficient numbers. A hundred thousand emails and phone calls should be more productive
than a single petition with 100,000 signatures.
There is no guarantee of victory. There is a guarantee of
defeat if we stand by and let someone else take care of this for us. With a few
exceptions, the Democratic Party has proven unable to meet the current
challenge in any effective manner; we must pick up their slack. You’re either
for the America we were taught we lived in, or you’re against it.
Yesterday I went to downtown Washington DC to see firsthand the effect, if any, of having the National Guard and federal law enforcement supplement the DC police in the most touristed area of the city: the National Mall. Estimated walking distance from onthegomap.com: 6.61 miles. (Editor’s note: I am too old for this shit. Next time I get such a brilliant idea I’m going to drink a frosty cold glass of Sit the Fuck Down until it passes. Or a piping hot mug, depending on the season.)
·
I spoke to 12 National Guard troops on the Mall.
Regardless of what we think of 47’s decision to put them there, all of them
were polite and friendly young men who were happy to talk to me. They represent
us well and we should be proud to have such fine young men in our service.
·
When I ask if their current duty was the kind of
thing they signed up for, the majority declined to comment, often citing “operation
security.” I get that. I was among the first to be trained in co-ed companies
back in 1980. 60 Minutes came on the base to conduct interviews. My
company was called into formation, where SSG Willie Green gave us the following
pep talk: “Those TV people may ask you your opinion. Your opinion is, you gots
no opinion. Dismissed.” There are rights you sign away when joining the
military. The Army is very clear about that, and I get it. I respected those
Guardsmen’s position and did not push.
·
One commented that this was what he signed up
for, “to see the country. I’m loving this.” When I asked about the specific
task, he cited operational security.
·
A soldier from West Virginia remarked on what a
beautiful city Washington is, and how he’ll be back.
·
My favorite response to “Is this the kind of
duty you signed up for when you enlisted” was, “Absolutely……..not.”
·
I saw no federal law enforcement outside of a Capitol
Police K-9 officer patrolling the grounds and two DHS police officers talking
to a couple of Amtrak cops in Union Station.
·
I saw 46 National Guards I did not speak to,
either because of distance or walking in the wrong direction.
·
Six young men who were obviously military were sightseeing
on their day off and having a ball.
·
I encountered only two DC cops. One drove by on
his motorcycle. The other gave me directions when I asked. She, too, could not
have been nicer.
·
I spoke with a handful of Guardsmen at the Union
Station Metro and learned they’re being put up in local hotels. I have to
wonder how much of this “emergency deployment” is a way to get hoteliers off
the Administration’s back by replacing some of their lost tourist revenue with National
Guards.
·
I saw quite a few uniformed troops while eating
lunch in Union Station’s food court, but all but a handful were either eating
or carrying bags of food. Those who were not were being escorted in the
direction of the food court by an Amtrak cop.
·
Not a trace of ICE.
·
A major surprise: At least half the people I saw
walking around as tourists spoke Spanish to each other.
·
This one’s for you, Charlie Stella: I followed the
sounds of sirens, thinking there might be police activity. What I found were
half a dozen Palestinian protesters with noise generators, banging on pots and
pans to protest events in Gaza. I went round to all of them to give a thumbs up
and shake hands.
·
A park ranger at the Vietnam Memorial said he didn’t
feel any more, or less, safe with the National Guard in town. He did say the
memorial was popular with the uniformed Guards..
The end result is I’m tired and I’m sore and I don’t think I
accomplished anything except for spreading goodwill to a dozen or so people and
working off some of my own frustrations. On the other hand, I did find three
restrooms on the Mall for future reference, which is a big deal for a man with a
prostate five months shy of seventy years old and taking medication that
encourages – no, demands – frequent urination.
Those of us born in the 1950s have seen great improvements in the quality of life across the board, not the least of which are the improvements in the lives of those who have traditionally been marginalized. Women, people of color, the LGBTQIA+ community, and non-Christians all saw their status improve through the 60s and into at least the early 80s. It became easy to believe such improvements were the natural order of things.
Now we’re faced with the rollback of all that and then some.
Authoritarians – the politically correct term for fascists, which has itself
become the PC term for Nazis – would have you believe this is the natural order.
White men should rule a semi-feudal world in which everyone else either falls
into line or disappears. Voluntarily, if they choose, but someone will come for
you if you’re slow to get the message.
The good news is, they’re wrong. The trend of human history
has consistently been toward more independence and cooperation. It has not
progressed in a straight line – history never does, no matter how inevitable
things seem in retrospect – but the trend is clear. Taking a step or two back for every two or
three forward is frustrating for those who have to live through it, especially
if one believes the passages in the Declaration of Independence and the
Constitution that refer to “all people” or “no person may be denied.” I am
convinced the pendulum will again swing in our direction.
The bad news? Well there are a couple of items on that list:
1.
My generation may not live to see it.
2.
It’s not going to happen at all unless more
people get off their asses.
We’re in this predicament, in large part, because over a
third of registered voters didn’t bother to do so last November. Now that we have
concrete evidence of 47’s intent, we’re hamstrung by the LibDem belief that how
you say something is more important than what you say and dear God we don’t
want to piss anyone off.
I follow several groups that showed promise of being
Resistance leaders in the early days of 47’s administration; too much of their
efforts focus on requesting signatures on online petitions, donations, or small
local gatherings. One in particular has damn near sprained its collective
shoulder patting itself on the back for delivering a petition to Congress with
75,000 signatures.
Why am I so dismissive of this? It only shows that 0.16% of
registered Democrats were outraged enough to make two mouse clicks. This is not
going to move the needle. Would it not be far more effective for their senators
and representatives to have received 75,000 e-mails or phone calls or letters? Even
better, for 75,000 people to show up at the Capitol, preferably with pitchforks
and torches?
“But most people don’t live close enough to Washington to
get there.” True, but. There are 6.3 million people in the DC metro area, which
is largely blue. Seventy-five thousand is only 1.19% of that.
The Beloved Spouse™ and I took part in the Women’s March in
January 2017 to protest what was then 45’s inauguration. Crowd estimates ranged
from 500,000 to 1.2 million. That crowd gathered to protest the mere threat of
what 45 might do.
Now we’re faced with the reality of what 47 is doing. I went
to the Women’s March in January, and other rallies and protests in March,
April, May, and July 4. In my admittedly crude estimation, the 2017 event drew
more bodies than everything I’ve seen this year combined. (It is only fair that
I point out I was unable to attend the “No Kings” rally on June 14.)
The Vietnam War protests worked because they generated
sufficient outrage within the general population to convince elected officials
to get us out. Not by blowing up buildings; that only pissed people off. I’m
talking about the large-scale protests that attracted media attention and
showed the nation at large how people who were practicing non-violent civil
disobedience were being beaten and gassed. When the powers that be saw people
were serious enough to risk arrest or worse, things changed.
Today we face a far more existential crisis. Where is
everyone? Why hasn’t there been a mass rally in Washington DC since June 14? Is
it harder to get permits? Fuck the permits. The 47 administration has no reason
to grant such permits, because those are the kinds of events that will generate
media attention, much as the Vietnam War and Civil Rights rallies that clogged
the Mall in the 60s and 70s did.
Or the “rally” at the Capitol January 6, 2021.
Where is the outrage? You post memes on Facebook? Stop
jacking off to make yourself feel better and take action that might accomplish something.
There are several things wrong with the Resistance right
now, but among the most troubling is the absence of a leader to coalesce around.
Someone who’s not afraid to call for mass civil disobedience. That’s what it
took for civil rights, and to end the Vietnam War. That’s what it’s going to
take here. Many more people with their hearts in the right place need to put
their asses there, too.
If someone comes to me with information about a gathering
where civil disobedience will take place and I can get there, I’ll go. That’s
why I’m so worked up. I am unaware of any such activities.
I’ll keep looking, though
(This was drafted a couple of weeks ago. Since then several
officials, mostly governors, notably Gavin Newsome, have begun to step up. I
applaud their efforts and hope they inspire others who seek our votes and spend
our money to do the same.)
(PS
You might well wonder what I’m doing aside from blogging and
posting to social media. It’s a fair question.
So far I’ve attended half a dozen marches and rallies in Washington,
donated several hundred dollars to organizations such as those I’m now
disenchanted with, along with the ACLU, which will get the lion’s share of any
future giving. I sent e-mail to two or more elected official three times a
week, and have written letters to administration officials and the Supreme
Court to oppose some of the more egregious transgressions. I’m going into DC August
21 to walk the Mall and ask any uniformed National Guards I see if acting as an
army of occupation is what they signed up for.)
There’s a reason ICE personnel wear masks and do not provide ID:
· An 82-year-old Pennsylvania man who’s lived in this country legally for 38 years was captured and deported while at an immigration office to replace the green card that was in his lost wallet.
· People are arrested as they enter or exit their legally scheduled – and supposedly legally binding – immigration hearings.
· Children are taken from school so their parents can be arrested when they come to pick the kids up. (The technical term for this is ‘hostage taking.”)
· Criminals are released to provide more throughput to deport asylum seekers. (Per the Cato Institute: “New Data on Trump’s Border Security Record: Releasing Criminals to Jail Asylum Seekers.” If you’re not familiar with the Cato Institute, it is not a bleeding heart liberal organization. It’s a libertarian think tank founded in 1977 by Charles Koch, among others.)
· An entire Puerto Rican family was taken into custody in Milwaukee for speaking Spanish. Puerto Ricans are American citizens.
You don’t need me to go on in this vein. The daily outrages are easy to find.
ICE is the closest thing we have in this country to the Gestapo. They must be resisted by all available means, including civil disobedience and disruption of operations when necessary. I always said defunding the police was bullshit, but eliminating ICE may be necessary to preserve the rule of law in what is left of our democracy.
ICE officers are not heroes, keeping America safe from foreign criminals. If they were, we’d see reports of the arrests and deportation Eastern European mob members. ICE enforcement personnel and cowards, hiding behind masks because they know what they’re doing is wrong. They’re thugs, because they’re committing acts of illegal physical violence.
And they are violating the oath they took when they got the job and should be subject to the penalties outlined in 18 USC 1918/5. To wit:
“I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; that I take this obligation freely, without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion; and that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties of the office on which I am about to enter. So help me God.”
The Fourth Amendment reads:
“The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.”
ICE, and their capo di tutti capi, also known as 47, freely admit they violate this on a routine basis.
ICE has to go. We’ll need something in its place, but the core of the organization is so vile we’re going to have to burn it down and start from scratch. After locking up quite a few of the current regime.
The other night The Beloved Spouse™ and I watched Anthropoid, a World War 2 thriller based on the true story of the mission to assassinate SS General Reinhard Heydrich, the main architect behind Nazi Germany’s “Final Solution,” and known as “The Butcher of Prague.” It’s an excellent film on multiple levels and I highly recommend it.
It's also thought-provoking, given our current situation. Make no mistake, I am not comparing conditions in the United States in 2025 to what existed in Prague in 1938. What those people lived through is too hideous to contemplate. Even the worst of 47’s plans for immigrants and other chosen groups pale in comparison to the execution 5,000 Czechs in retaliation for Heydrich’s assassination, or the routine taking of hostages to “encourage” the betrayal of Resistance fighters.
Watching the film, I tried to put myself in the place of several of the characters, including those who lived in Czechoslovakia all along, and those who got out and parachuted back in to aid in the Resistance; I couldn’t do it. My personal experience makes a true understanding of their courage and self-sacrifice beyond my comprehension.
There is one similarity that struck me: the Czechs had no idea how long they’d have to keep this up. Chamberlain had sold them out and they were on their own until the United Kingdom entered the was after the Nazi invasion of Poland a year after Anthropoid takes place. (In fairness, the Brits were training those who parachuted back into Czechoslovakia to support the Resistance.)
Our situation is similar, if not as dire. We need to make up our minds to show courage and a willingness to sacrifice if we are to keep 47 and his MAGgots from destroying everything accomplished in this country over the past 100 years. While our conditions are nowhere near as bad as those faced by the European Resistance fighters during the war, we do lack one thing that helped to sustain them once the war was fully joined.
No one is coming to save us.
The time for polite talk and gatherings has passed. Chants of “Trump must go now!” are meaningless, given the current makeup of Congress. The encouragement of “good trouble” is masturbatory so long as “good trouble” means gathering, chanting, and marching with permits.
The upper echelons of the MAGgot movement are laughing at us. Does anyone reading this thing 47 or Vice President Possumfucker or Auschwitz Barbie or AG Barbie HHS Secretary Jack D. Ripper gives half a fuck about any of that?
They have to at least be inconvenienced. Gatherings of several hundred people – or more; more is always better - in front of ICE or DHS or DOJ, or the FBI, or HHS, or Congress who got together without prior permission and have to be forcible removed would be a good start.
I’m not talking about violence. Law enforcement comes to clear the area, sit down. Go limp. Do not allow yourself to be escorted out; make them carry you. Whatever might get on the evening news or go viral to inspire the people outside the Beltway to take action of their own.
Such an approach worked during the Vietnam War, and what we’re facing here is a far more existential threat to this country than that war was. Yes, people are going to go to jail. Some will be gassed. Some may be beaten or worse. We all have to decide for ourselves what democracy is worth.
I’ve made my decision. Now I just need someone to point me, and not in the direction of more of the same.